Is It Cake? Valentines Winner Explained (Netflix Special)

,

Is It Cake? Valentines Winner Explained: Who Won and What Cake Fooled Them?

Spoilers ahead for Is It Cake? Valentines (released February 4, 2026).

Quick spoiler answer: who won?

Based on post-show coverage of the couples’ outcomes, Kimberly & Taurus Adams appear to be the winners of Netflix’s Is It Cake? Valentines. Here’s the simple logic: both Alex & Amanda Rivera and Jason Hisley & Tyler Alexander Stiff are reported as being unable to make it past Round 1 after their bake was identified as cake, leaving Kimberly & Taurus as the only team not described as eliminated in Round 1.

That means the “cake that fooled them” is the one made by Kimberly & Taurus—the only illusion the celebrity judges failed to correctly spot in the main deception round. (At the time of writing, I could not locate a reliable text source that clearly states the exact object their cake replicated.)

Watch the trailer & clips (YouTube)

What Is It Cake? Valentines is (format, runtime, judges)

  • Format: A Valentine’s-themed special where real-life couples team up to build hyper-realistic “illusion cakes.”
  • Episode count: 1 special episode (about 44 minutes).
  • Host: Mikey Day.
  • Celebrity judges: Ashlee Simpson & Evan Ross, plus Casey Wilson & David Caspe.
  • Prizes: The winning team earns cash and advances to a bonus prize round with a cruise-style grand reward.

If you’ve watched the main series, the core idea is the same: the bakers are trying to beat your brain’s shortcut for “real vs. fake.” If the cake matches the decoys on shape, scale, surface texture, and color, judges start second-guessing everything—especially under time pressure.

Meet the three couples who competed

Kimberly & Taurus Adams

Kimberly “Sweets” Adams is known for competition baking, and this special paired her with her husband Taurus as her teammate. Their win (as implied by other couples’ Round 1 outcomes) fits the show’s usual pattern: the team that best “disappears” into the decoy lineup forces judges to pick wrong.

Alex & Amanda Rivera

In their Valentine’s bake, Alex & Amanda recreated a romantic moment from their own story: a velvet pillow topped with a magic lamp (a nod to an Aladdin-themed proposal). They were eliminated after Round 1 when judges identified their piece as cake, reportedly because the proportions read slightly “bigger than real” compared to the decoys.

Jason Hisley & Tyler Alexander Stiff

Jason & Tyler also did not advance past Round 1, with post-show coverage stating their bake was identified as cake. Their on-show concept was inspired by their honeymoon in Greece (described as a “statue cake” idea in relationship coverage).

So… what cake actually fooled the judges?

In a standard Is It Cake? setup, the “winning” deception is the one the judges fail to call out as cake when it’s sitting among decoys. For Is It Cake? Valentines, the publicly described Round 1 outcomes for the other two couples strongly imply that Kimberly & Taurus’s illusion cake is the one that successfully blended into the lineup and fooled the panel.

If you want the “how,” not just the “what,” here are the details that usually make (or break) a judge’s guess:

  • Scale discipline: Even a perfect texture fails if the object is 3–5% too large.
  • Edge logic: Real items have crisp edges, seams, folds, or manufacturing lines. Cakes often look softly rounded.
  • Finish control: Fondant and chocolate can reflect light differently than plastic, paper, fabric, or wax.
  • Color noise: “Too perfect” color can look fake; tiny scuffs, specks, and unevenness read as real.

Reddit reactions: the one-episode surprise

The biggest viewer surprise wasn’t even the cakes—it was learning the Valentine’s drop was just one episode. On Reddit, fans also debated whether the episode’s deception level felt easier than the main seasons and whether judging felt “shifty.”

What even was the Valentine's Day thing?
by u/New-Union9908 in r/isitcakenetflix

What Reddit Theories Say About this (judging, fairness, “partner skill gap”)

One recurring Reddit point: couples aren’t always evenly matched on baking experience, which can change the strategy. A pro cake artist paired with a non-baker has to choose between “training up” the partner (costs time) or designing a build that keeps the partner productive without risking the illusion.

Another theme: viewers want the show to keep the illusion “pure”—no messing with decoys, no edits that make the answer feel predetermined, and judging that rewards both deception and cake quality.

Twitter/X and Instagram buzz (live feeds)

Instagram is often where the contestants post behind-the-scenes photos, cake close-ups, and watch-party moments. You can also look up the couple-run bakery brand mentioned in coverage: A Couple of Layers on Instagram (instagram.com/acouple.layers).

FAQ

Is Is It Cake? Valentines a full season?

No. It’s a one-episode Valentine’s special (around 44 minutes).

Who are the judges on Is It Cake? Valentines?

Ashlee Simpson & Evan Ross, plus Casey Wilson & David Caspe (with Mikey Day hosting).

Who won Is It Cake? Valentines?

Based on reported Round 1 outcomes for the other teams, Kimberly & Taurus Adams appear to be the winners. (If Netflix publishes an official winner recap naming the exact object cake, this section can be updated.)

Related watchlist picks (if you’re in an Is It Cake mood)

  • Is It Cake? (main series seasons)
  • Is It Cake? Halloween (holiday spin-off)
  • Is It Cake? Holiday (winter/holiday spin-off)